Domestic Dispute Leads to Stabbing
The following information is gathered from the St. Clair Shores Police Department. Arrests do not indicate conviction.
A 43-year-old St. Clair Shroes woman was arraigned in 40th District Court Tuesday on a charge of assault with intent to do great bodily harm for allegedly stabbing her boyfriend in the house they shared in the 21000 block of Erben.
Christine Holstine allegedly got in a dispute Sunday with her live-in boyfriend and stabbed him in the shoulder with a kitchen knife, according to St. Clair Shores Police Det. Gordon Carrier.
She is being held in the Macomb County Jail on $100,000 bond and is to have no contact with the victim. She has a pre-trial hearing March 12.
Her boyfriend, 42, remains hospitalized and will be charged with domestic violence, Carrier added.
VJ Cannistraci
12:47 pm on Wednesday, March 6, 2013
The guy is going to get arrested for being stabbed? Ohh my cow!!
John Smith
12:00 am on Thursday, March 7, 2013
well if the guy was stabbed and is in a hospital I think he suffers enough even though it was a domestic dispute he's the 1 that got stabbed it's just the cities way to get more money out of something that they really don't know anything about automatically they going to charge 1 so why not lets charge the other 1 and get more money for the city so they can continue building a brand new courthouse it's a shame of people are treated even know there's a victim they still get charged accused of doing something
shelly deville
5:10 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
well the arrgivated assault was charged to him, which you all failed to realize and the self defense was in her favor hence case being dismissed, so no felony charges and no story to tell
John Smith
12:07 am on Thursday, March 7, 2013
whoever wrote this post really needs to investigate more and get their facts straight I know these people personally and I know for a fact that gentleman does not live in that house or with her he has his own house in the city of Warrebut I am sure that he spends the night there occasionally there's nothing wrong with that that's what people doso you should get your facts right before you post something and accuse people of doing things that they're not shame on you again Saint Clair Shores shame on you
Juanita Doe
11:04 am on Thursday, March 7, 2013
gentleman...don't make me laugh
Juanita Doe
3:49 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
His facebook page says he lives in St. Clair Shores
shelly deville
5:08 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
kudo's to the intelligent john smith and bringing the attention to the fact he had his own house in warren .. applause please for facts being stated
Jane Doe
12:20 am on Thursday, March 7, 2013
I can't believe the guy is getting charged in this!! I guess the real question in the matter would be why? For getting stabbed? How is that domestic violence on his part? Geez the system really is about money!
From this reading it doesn't say anything about what he did to obtain this accusations towards him.
shelly deville
5:07 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
Exactly, FALSE reporting on and shame on SCS Patch for not reporting the REAL story. Half ass isnt the way to write this stuff up, They only create confusion and drama. And neither have any previous convictions and neither have a criminal history, its public record, look it up.
Jane Doe
12:23 am on Thursday, March 7, 2013
And another thing. If this guy lives there, don't you think he wouldn't want any of this?! Not saying he wouldn't if he didn't I'm just saying. Do these officers really think that people do this for fun?
It's an unfortunate event that happened in this house hold but at the same time. Don't sit here and charge everyone with something. St Clair shores as a city is becoming a joke. The system is a joke, everything.
Thinker
10:18 am on Thursday, March 7, 2013
Perhaps she stabbed him in self-defense? Why else would they charge him?
Juanita Doe
11:03 am on Thursday, March 7, 2013
I am sure he is not innocent. This is not the first time they have had domestic violence calls/charges against them...BOTH of them
Thinker
3:36 pm on Friday, March 8, 2013
Bets on whether they stay together? Sounds like a hot mess! Hope the kids are being cared for...
shelly deville
5:04 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
hmmm thinker? good question, think they left that part out of the story they reported
Jill Doe
10:35 am on Thursday, March 7, 2013
This girl is a nut job, and I know that from personal experience with her! And they DO live in that house together. The issue is not whether they live together or not, the issue is that she stabbed him, and now she's in jail for it. She has been arrested multiple times for domestic violence. This isn't her first rodeo! She is a heavy drinker, a bully, and just an awful person in general!
Juanita Doe
2:59 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
that fake tan, fake nails and designer purses aren't going to do her any good in jail, are they? Feel sorry for her kids
Jill Doe
5:14 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
Ha! You are right about that Juanita! Fake, fake, fake!
shelly deville
5:03 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
a bully, christine lol. the one who rescues animals, volunteers, and feeds homeless who live under bridges, ya thats my guess that she 's a bully.
Juanita Doe
11:01 am on Thursday, March 7, 2013
This is what happen when a crack head and an alcoholic live together in a section 8 rental house. White trash at its finest
Samantha
8:25 pm on Friday, March 8, 2013
Haha I have to say it takes one to know one. The only people who make and talk from a FAKE account have things to hide
shelly deville
5:01 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
nice try on the section 8, sounds like you yourself are all to familiar with the system, FACT is she has never collected assistance from any program in 10 years of raising them children on her own, ITS called a JOB and shes worked for over 20 years and if u were wise ud know u cant receive assistance when you make MONEY.
Penny Jones
12:08 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
Well as Sheldon once said, "WATCH YOUR BACK JACK, BITCHES BE CRAZY!
Jane doe
4:29 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
Oh my. You people are ruthless! Who woulda thought people are so quick to judge. Do any of you know these people personally? Do any of you judgemental human beings have any idea what either of these people are going through?
One of you is making accusations of the man beating her, the other are making accusations of drugs. It's a shame how you all are acting.
Do any of you have proof of any of the accusations being stated towards this man? Didn't think so.
If you don't have proof, maybe you all should shut you're mouth. As far as the woman goes again. If you don't have proof, solid proof, then don't talk. It's an unfortunate thing that happened to these two individuals, but at the same time, who are any of you to past judgement? Saints? I doubt that.
Jill Doe
5:12 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
Yep....know them personally, and sounds like "Juanita" does too. Yes, she is an alcoholic, yes, he is a crackhead, and yes, they are complete white trash! And yes, they do live in that house on Erben together. Any more questions?!?! Perhaps you shouldn't accuse people of being "judgemental" or "ruthless", because for all you think you know, you know NOTHING!! I have watched this ridiculous relationship for YEARS now, with BOTH of them being arrested for domestic violence, and enough is enough! It was just a matter of time until it happened again. So, Jane Doe, ya might want to take a hike, move on to another thread, because you have no idea what you are talking about, and I DO!
Jane doe
4:43 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
Juanita, question. So his Facebook page says he lives in st Clair shores? Oh my! I didn't know there was only one home in st Clair shores. So because Facebook (the most childish reference known to man kind) says it. It's true? HA! Typical juvenile, adolescence. You my dear Juanita, are a gem..
Jill Doe
5:16 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
And you Jane, are a joke! People like you that have no idea what they are talking about online should not be allowed internet access!
shelly deville
4:59 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
jill doe sounds like a single cat lady.... lol. so you know them 1st hand so you admit you associate with addicts and white trash? You know them so well? Comical little thing arnt you. Why are you following their relationship? Do you have a life of your own? Its my advice that you seek some mental counseling for stalking. I dont mind hanging out with a kind woman who is an administrative assistant to 3 companies, has 2 productive amazing children and many friends and family supporting her. God bless them all in there battle with the ignorant
Jane doe
6:16 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
I know more than you think. I know both parties much better than you think. So wanna reveal who you are, and I'll reveal who I am. Maybe I'll know you. Maybe I won't. But bottom line. I know more about this than you ever will. I know the temperaments of both parties better than most. I know the back ground of the gentleman better than anyone. So you, may want to take a hike.
shelly deville
4:45 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
hmmm I doubt you know the him better than me since ive known him since high school
theresa
11:23 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
i have a feeling this is a family member of the gentlemen.....
Jane doe
6:23 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
And another, how was I wrong with YOU being judgemental?
Fake nails, fake tan, and name bran bags..sounds to me like she takes care of herself. That's a sign of jealously dear, it's quite contagious, you may want to get help.
As for the man Involved. Let me guess you know this how?
White trash? From what I've seen they live a pretty good life. So? Next?
shelly deville
4:43 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
not sure who this is, but yes I agree good hygiene is not a crime. God bless a woman who works 50 hours a week, raised 2 good children and takes care of herself.
Jill Doe
8:19 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
Jane, Reveal myself? Why? So I can become the next victim of this violent couple? I think not! And for the record, a "gentleman" would never ever lay a hand on a "lady", and vice versa. You see, we are not seeing a "gentleman" and a "lady" here, they are violent animals with substance abuse problems. Multiple arrests on both ends for domestic violence shows a clear history of problems. That in no way is evidence of living a "good life". With that, I bid you goodbye, good luck with your friends.
Samantha
1:55 pm on Friday, March 8, 2013
I am going to take a wild guess and assume all the people on here are over 19?..Assuming my assumptions are right. Then I would have to say you "adults" are really mature making FAKE accounts and commenting on other peoples lives..
To sit here and call someone FAKE from a FAKE account is HILARIOUS.
Makes me laugh to see that "adults" are worried about my generation when the ones that are worried are the ones who do not know how to act. Shameful.
Stephanie Woolridge
8:26 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
LOL! The comments are better than the actual story. This is like Jerry Springer online.
What up, Doe's?
Peter
8:45 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
Very sad for the children who are living there!
Peter
9:16 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
This property is owned and operated by the City of St. Clair Shores. You would think city officials would complete background checks on all individuals in the household. I live one block away and i can tell you there have been numerous police and fire calls to the home, and by the way, let there be NO MISTAKE, the boyfriend lives at the home 24 x 7. The woman was arrested for domestic violence in June 2012 . . . . . wow what a surprise. The boyfriend was arrested on Harper Avenue last summer (not sure for what). What a great couple living off taxpayers. I guess the best we can hope for is for the city to hold the home until their legal wranglings are over. These adults show no respect or common sense for taxpayers who cover part of their monthly rent and general upkeep. Shameful!
shelly deville
4:41 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
now this is where you are 100% incorrect, Call roseann minnie at scs rehabilation, GET your facts dumbass. Dont be scared to seek the truth, it will set your evil soul free
Samantha
1:46 pm on Friday, March 8, 2013
This is all SOOOOO comical! Everyone on here is a joke. And SO quick to judge when NONE of you are saints.Get a damn life,for real. NONE of you have a clue what happens in this house. And I know no one speaking has clean hands. If you want the truth and know these people so well why don't you all just ask the source. Her or her boyfriend personally, huh? or maybe ME!
Each one of you needs to get a life and mind your own business.
The "boyfriend"-Don't live in the house
Everyone needs to GET THEIR FACTS STRAIGHT! She has a job and two fabulous children that she raised ON HER OWN! Bottom line is mind your own business, get a life. I am sorry to hear that all of your lives suck so bad that you have nothing better to do. I hope you all the best and that you find peace in your lives so that you don't have to look at other peoples lives and bash other people to make yourselves feel better.
Peter
4:29 pm on Friday, March 8, 2013
I would like to speak to the source, but I don't have the time to visit them in jail. Do you have their number? I mean cell phone number, not jail house number.
Samantha
5:50 pm on Friday, March 8, 2013
Yeah actually I do how about you email me holstins@mail.gvsu.edu ask me what you want to ask since you have NOTHING better to do.
shelly deville
4:38 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
No prior convictions for either, no drug offenses, no alcohol offenses, no criminal convictions, they must be the most functioning addicts ever, lol. Complete and utter joke, all of you.
Mike
4:38 pm on Friday, March 8, 2013
Tell Em Sammy-doo.
Sherrie Mills
2:57 pm on Saturday, March 9, 2013
You people are very sad !Sammi dont engage in there BS. we dont care what any of them think.A Bunch Of COWARDS.
shelly deville
4:33 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
The house in scs isnt hud or government funded. So, so much for what these dumb asses think they know. The rent goes according to income thru the shores rehabilatation program and they get no money for these homes other than rent and they own over 60 homes within this program, and none of you know her income so dont know what her rent is. From what ive seen the yard is landscaped by her personally, sod, bushes, flowers, brick pavers. shes carpeted, painted, and maintained house 100% without one violation in 8 years.
shelly deville
4:34 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
I happened to be at bbq's in the summer and seen 1st hand fire trucks being sent for bon fires, in legal pits, now there's a waste of tax payers money, or sent for people being in yard at 8-10 pm playing cards on patio, radio on, and never once was she ever cited, hmm? Our sons were playing basketball in driveway with the portable pole hoop and the cops showed up to have them move it away from sidewalk, pathetic, they showed up when r boys were working on mini bikes and running them up and down driveway and yard, completely LEGAL, another waster of time,
shelly deville
4:34 pm on Thursday, March 14, 2013
She has no drug history and drinks socially and parties when the party arrives, her daughter is at college and her son is amazing. The house is spotless and taken care of at her expense. She works and cares for her children, her personal relationship with man in question is sad, sometimes things get bad, and relationships go south, like in divorce, noone knows what lead to this or why and who are we to judge? Christine is a good friend and mother, daughter and auntie and if you knew her u'd know that. Look in your own mirror and focus on your own flaws, clean up your own yard. This horrible woman you speak of worked for eastpointe court for 4 years and SCS for 2 years. As for the man in question and his drug issue, well so be it, Pray he gets help, nothing good comes of the nastiness you put into the world with your negativity and violent verbal attack on others. Lead with kindness and compassion, you just might make the world a better place. And the FACT is this man had a home in warren he's resided at for 13 months now on lasalle street, FACTS are Facts people, if you feel the need to know, ASK?
Lynn
12:37 pm on Friday, March 15, 2013
I know of this "happy couple" as well. I've seen pictures of one of the times she assulted him in the past - she has claws like a cat! This arrest that she plead GUILTY too is not surprising at all... very entertaining for a boring day at work - cant wait to see who stabs who next :)
Maddie Reberry
9:16 am on Sunday, March 17, 2013
Shame on everyone one of you that have nothing better in your lives than thrive on others pain. The negativity that follows the people above, around surely sours their day to day lives. There is one ultimate judge in everything....honestly people...wait that is kind. Honestly, you morons, do you believe every rendition of every story you read\hear? Good grief I hope not. I know all of you are equipped well enough to read....but, can you think for yourselves that's the question. Get a grip, a life, a hobby something for the love of God. Shelly Deville you put everything so eloquently, for this I thank you. The world needs more people like you to grace its surface.
amber
12:03 pm on Monday, March 18, 2013
its sounds like this couple needs some Professional help, because this is not there first time. I myself have seen what his lady has done in the past to him, and it is not a heathy relationship, and yes she was in mcj last june on the same charges, but they were dropped because of the man not wanting her to go to jail. I just hope this man comes to his senses because next time she just might kill him..